Handwriting - should it stay or should it go?
Thursday, 13 March 2008

Our new bottles are hitting the shelves at last.
And we're waiting nervously to hear what people think of what we've done to the back. or rather what we've left out... the nice little scrawls, circles and comments we used to scribble on them.
(Here's the back of a 2003 bottle, in case you missed it.)
We added the handwriting because we hoped it would make the drinks feel a bit more "friendly" and "personal" - we even signed "Harry & Marcus" on the bottles.
So what's not to like?
Firstly, handwriting has become a bit of a cliché - the moment the supermarkets start wading in with own-label drinks covered in handwriting, you begin to think it's time to move on.
Secondly, it feels a bit "false" - clearly, we don't walk round the bottling plant, scribbling on every bottle. So there's something vaguely disingenuous about it - like people who use a GIF signature on their letters. And several people we asked assumed that Harry & Marcus were probably characters invented by a big corporation. (We exist! We breathe, we eat, please believe us!)
And thirdly, whilst the scribbles really stand out and attract attention, we suspect they make the rest of the text harder to read. So is it better for everyone to just read a few scribbles, or hope that a few more people will read a bit more (even if a few then read nothing at all)?
Hmmm.
What do you think?



